Chest fly alternatives

The pec deck, also called the butterfly machine, is the closest chest fly alternative. It's the same hugging motion on a fixed path with nothing to balance. Cable crossovers keep tension on your chest through the whole rep.

How to do the dumbbell flyes

What makes the chest fly hard to replace

  • A wide hugging arc

    Your arms stay slightly bent and swing together in a wide arc, so your chest does the work with little help from your triceps.

  • A stretch at the bottom

    Dumbbell flyes are hardest with your arms open wide, where your chest is stretched.

  • Light weights

    Flyes put a lot of leverage on your shoulders, so they work best for 10 to 15 controlled reps.

Same dumbbells, different bench

  • Incline flyes

    Set the bench to a low incline to shift the work toward your upper chest.

  • Floor flyes

    Lie on the floor so your elbows stop when they touch it. A safer way to learn the movement.

On a machine or cable

With dumbbells

At home

How the swaps compare

ExerciseA wide hugging arcA stretch at the bottomLight weights
ButterflyYesPartlyYes
Cable CrossoverYesPartlyYes
Incline Dumbbell FlyesYesYesYes
Cable Chest PressNoPartlyNo
Push-Up WideNoPartlyPartly

How much weight to use

Most beginners start dumbbell flyes with 10 to 20 lb in each hand. Pec deck numbers vary by machine, so pick a weight you can do for 12 slow reps.

For cable crossovers, each side goes lighter than most people expect. Start with one or two plates on each side and add one at a time.

How to pick

The dumbbells are taken
The pec deck or cable crossovers.
Flyes bother your shoulders
The pec deck, stopping before your hands pass your chest on the way back.
You want more upper chest
Incline dumbbell flyes or incline cable flyes.
You're training at home
Wide push-ups, slow on the way down.

Chest fly alternatives FAQ

What is the best alternative to chest flyes?

The pec deck. Same movement on a fixed path. Cable crossovers are close behind.

Is the pec deck as good as dumbbell flyes?

Yes for your chest. Dumbbells stretch your chest more at the bottom, and the pec deck keeps tension at the end of the rep.

Can push-ups replace chest flyes?

Partly. Wide push-ups work your chest, and since they're a press, your triceps help too.

How heavy should chest flyes be?

Light. Pick a weight you can lower slowly for 10 to 15 reps without bending your elbows further.

Guides

Try these swaps in LiftCamp